Do You Have the Right to Repair??

Posts

it's this kind of corporate crazy-ass shit that increases the appeal of the FOSS philosophy even to the larger audience of not-so-tech-savvy normies. Anyway, TOP CHORTLE at this ignoramus preaching about the virtues of innovation while at the same time advocating for the kind of mindset that slows the pace of free technological progress

floattube wrote

I paid money for it. I will do whatever I want with it.

I am in 100% agreeance. Unfortunately the powers that be are not; and it looks like the trend to restrict the rights the public has through technology will continue.

infornography wrote

it's this kind of corporate crazy-ass shit that increases the appeal of the FOSS philosophy even to the larger audience of not-so-tech-savvy normies. Anyway, TOP CHORTLE at this ignoramus preaching about the virtues of innovation while at the same time advocating for the kind of mindset that slows the pace of free technological progress

Do you think any amount of support FOSS can gain from this will matter in the long run, if legislation like Right to Repair isn't passed?

when the workers don't own the means of production, even if they bought the means of production

Somewhere in Germany, Marx is spinning in his grave.

bulb wrote
floattube wrote

I paid money for it. I will do whatever I want with it.

I am in 100% agreeance. Unfortunately the powers that be are not; and it looks like the trend to restrict the rights the public has through technology will continue.

infornography wrote

it's this kind of corporate crazy-ass shit that increases the appeal of the FOSS philosophy even to the larger audience of not-so-tech-savvy normies. Anyway, TOP CHORTLE at this ignoramus preaching about the virtues of innovation while at the same time advocating for the kind of mindset that slows the pace of free technological progress

Do you think any amount of support FOSS can gain from this will matter in the long run, if legislation like Right to Repair isn't passed?

the thing is, even if this bill weren't passed, I don't get how such an approach to the economy as a whole could be sustainable on the long-term for the big corps themselves: as I understand it, draconian regulations as the ones they're trying to push now assume that every big corp is only out for itself and see the economy as a zero-sum game playground, but by doing so they're enforcing stagnant monopolies and killing the potential profits that come with a more dynamic competition between software vendors. also, their "piracy" problem is here to stay: first off, they wouldn't be able to suppress what they regard as "copyright violation" in an effective way, second: do they really think that the mississippi farmers are the main intellectual property menace? lmao, the main threat to copyright comes from the great china <3 and since it's rising to the next global superpower, their piracy problem isn't going away anytime soon so topkek and jokes on them.

and btw yeah FOSS isn't gonna become an existential threat to the corporate world in the foreseeable future, but the more things like that are gonna happen the more new people will join the movement and therefore the wider the free-open source software ecosystem will become for the sheer delight of all of us autists

Even if this insanity was somehow passed and they put this into effect, there are some parts with no need to have a connection to a computer, So how would they even know if the person who purchased it was repairing it unless they for example stuck a sensor to every last part of the machine. and even then that would cost them a lot comapared to just dropping this madness. just sometimes corparate greed goes way too far. unless theres some part of this i am completely misunderstanding. if so please correct me. (Please Pardon any bad english)

a month later

I have the right to repair but I understand that my warranty is remove if I do. A lot of people would try to repair without knowing shit and break the stuff instead. So I understand why the warranty is removed if the product is open.

Yolan wrote

I have the right to repair but I understand that my warranty is remove if I do. A lot of people would try to repair without knowing shit and break the stuff instead. So I understand why the warranty is removed if the product is open.

I agree, but I think that isn't the problem here. The problem is when it's illegal to open, repair or modify a product that you own and that you legitimately purchased because copyright.

Sathariel wrote
Yolan wrote

I have the right to repair but I understand that my warranty is remove if I do. A lot of people would try to repair without knowing shit and break the stuff instead. So I understand why the warranty is removed if the product is open.

I agree, but I think that isn't the problem here. The problem is when it's illegal to open, repair or modify a product that you own and that you legitimately purchased because copyright.

I mean, how would they know if you opened it or not ? And.... what are they going to do, call the cops ?

"Allo, police? Yes, this dude opened the laptop he bought from us to repair the fan."
"Ok, so?"

"Well, we didn't authorize that ! So put this anarchist to jail !"
"You know that there are people being murdered and raped right now?"
"HE.TRY.TO.FIX.HIS.FAN"

Yolan wrote
Sathariel wrote
Yolan wrote

I have the right to repair but I understand that my warranty is remove if I do. A lot of people would try to repair without knowing shit and break the stuff instead. So I understand why the warranty is removed if the product is open.

I agree, but I think that isn't the problem here. The problem is when it's illegal to open, repair or modify a product that you own and that you legitimately purchased because copyright.

I mean, how would they know if you opened it or not ? And.... what are they going to do, call the cops ?

"Allo, police? Yes, this dude opened the laptop he bought from us to repair the fan."
"Ok, so?"

"Well, we didn't authorize that ! So put this anarchist to jail !"
"You know that there are people being murdered and raped right now?"
"HE.TRY.TO.FIX.HIS.FAN"

The issue in the US, I think, was mostly small businesses that specialise in phone, tablet, etc. repair were being sued by Apple for repairing their devices in exchange for money. It's unlikely that anything would ever happen if you try to repair your own device.

malmon wrote
Yolan wrote
Sathariel wrote
Yolan wrote

I have the right to repair but I understand that my warranty is remove if I do. A lot of people would try to repair without knowing shit and break the stuff instead. So I understand why the warranty is removed if the product is open.

I agree, but I think that isn't the problem here. The problem is when it's illegal to open, repair or modify a product that you own and that you legitimately purchased because copyright.

I mean, how would they know if you opened it or not ? And.... what are they going to do, call the cops ?

"Allo, police? Yes, this dude opened the laptop he bought from us to repair the fan."
"Ok, so?"

"Well, we didn't authorize that ! So put this anarchist to jail !"
"You know that there are people being murdered and raped right now?"
"HE.TRY.TO.FIX.HIS.FAN"

The issue in the US, I think, was mostly small businesses that specialise in phone, tablet, etc. repair were being sued by Apple for repairing their devices in exchange for money. It's unlikely that anything would ever happen if you try to repair your own device.

I remember this dude who was doing youtube video explaining how to fix iphone screen etc. Yes, he got in trouble.
Didn't see it this way because the title said "do you have the right to repair", as I think none of us are society or small business specialized in this thing, I thought he was talking at a personal level, but then I think yes, little business should have the right to repair too.