WARNING this is a HIGHLY controversial topic

Image no longer available

Its time to pick a side! 

Cake or Pie!

I eat both about equally. I dislike some cake, I dislike some pie. I'm abstaining from voting because I don't think I could choose a side.

You can have a smaller cake as a cupcake, but I never heard of a "cup"pie.
Therefore cake wins by default.

Saikou wrote

wow so many people are fucking wrong

I know, right?

Obviously, the correct answer is cookies.

Image no longer available

floattube wrote

Pie is fundamentally worse than cake in every way.

1v1 me irl chump

Backlash wrote
Saikou wrote

wow so many people are fucking wrong

I know, right?

Obviously, the correct answer is cookies.

Ah, I see you are qt of culture as well!

muffins and tiramisu are still the best though...   Image no longer available

Backlash wrote
Saikou wrote

wow so many people are fucking wrong

I know, right?

Obviously, the correct answer is cookies.

floattube wrote

Pie is fundamentally worse than cake in every way.

1v1 me irl chump

Lawly wrote
Backlash wrote
Saikou wrote

wow so many people are fucking wrong

I know, right?

Obviously, the correct answer is cookies.

Ah, I see you are qt of culture as well!

muffins and tiramisu are still the best though...

cookies+milk is top tier

16 days later

I must not be a true American because I don't like apple pie, or any other fruit-flavored pie. Pie is only good to me if it's chocolate based.

Cake, on the other hand, can be good in many ways. Though I normally don't like whole fruits in it. Something about the textures of gooey fruits and breads combined really doesn't work for me.

mmm, I'm not too sure, but I think cake! As long as it's not cheesecake!

malmon wrote

mmm, I'm not too sure, but I think cake! As long as it's not cheesecake!

Gawd, cheesecake makes me wanna gag. I knew a friend who swore by it, but I guess it just ain't for me. >_<

Backlash wrote
malmon wrote

mmm, I'm not too sure, but I think cake! As long as it's not cheesecake!

Gawd, cheesecake makes me wanna gag. I knew a friend who swore by it, but I guess it just ain't for me. >_<

I don't particularly mind it, I just don't really enjoy eating it either >.<

16 days later

Cake easily

KiMocci wrote

You can have a smaller cake as a cupcake, but I never heard of a "cup"pie.
Therefore cake wins by default.

A dumpling or a bun would be a lot like a cup pie

Kukuru wrote

Cake easily

KiMocci wrote

You can have a smaller cake as a cupcake, but I never heard of a "cup"pie.
Therefore cake wins by default.

A dumpling or a bun would be a lot like a cup pie

Don't forget mince pies!

Kukuru wrote
malmon wrote

mince pies!

no mincemeat

not a pie

savoury pies are a sin!

malmon wrote
Kukuru wrote
malmon wrote

mince pies!

no mincemeat

not a pie

savoury pies are a sin!

Why, I'll have you know Chicken Pot Pies are an American delicacy.